Puzzle Market Prices
Current eBay market data for 5,094 puzzle listings.
What you'll usually pay
💡 Used ones cost about 9% more here.
👉 In short easy summary
The best value is found in Toy Story puzzles, which sit 19% below the market median. Conversely, Be Puzzled brand items command a 24% premium over the median price.
💚 Best value for your money
Price by brand
Why? Prices vary by manufacturer, with Be Puzzled at the high end and Playskool 2% below median.
Price by character family
Why? Licensing affects value, ranging from Toy Story at 11.05 to Sesame Street at 17.99.
🛒 Some on sale right now
Common questions
What is the median price for a new puzzle?
The median price for new puzzles is 13.99.
Which brand has the most listings available?
Melissa & Doug has the most listings with 1,311.
Are used puzzles generally more expensive than new ones?
Yes, the used median is 15.26 compared to the new median of 13.99.
How we got these numbers
Worked out from 200 live eBay listings (price range $8–$30, odd outliers ignored). These are asking prices, so use them as a guide. Last checked June 28, 2026.