Home › Other Collectible Pencils

Collectible Pencil Prices

Market data for 41,008 collectible pencil listings.

What you'll usually pay

$18 typical price

Most are between$7–$75

Brand new$19.99

Used$24.99

On sale now41,008

💡 Used ones cost about 25% more here.

👉 In short easy summary

The best value is found in unbranded options, which have a -22% delta. High-end value is concentrated in Sterling Silver materials (+180%) and Black Wing branded pencils (+77%).

📈 Price history

Tracked daily since June 22, 2026 — median $18 → $19.99 (+11%).

🔄 What changed

Jul 28▲ PRICEMedian price rose 8% ($17.55 → $18.99)

Jul 27▼ PRICEMedian price dropped 12% ($19.99 → $17.55)

Jul 25▲ PRICEMedian price rose 14% ($17.5 → $19.97)

Jul 24▼ PRICEMedian price dropped 5% ($18.5 → $17.5)

Jul 20▼ PRICEMedian price dropped 10% ($19.99 → $17.99)

Jul 19▲ PRICEMedian price rose 5% ($18.99 → $19.99)

Jul 17▲ PRICEMedian price rose 8% ($17.5 → $18.91)

Jul 16▼ PRICEMedian price dropped 10% ($19.45 → $17.5)

Jul 15▲ PRICEMedian price rose 17% ($16.64 → $19.45)

Jul 14▼ PRICEMedian price dropped 12% ($18.97 → $16.64)

Jul 13▲ PRICEMedian price rose 19% ($15.95 → $18.97)

Jul 12▼ PRICEMedian price dropped 11% ($18 → $15.95)

💚 Best value for your money

Unbranded 8,433 on sale$14 · 22% cheaper

Gold 679 on sale$15 · 17% cheaper

Plastic 2,044 on sale$16.99 · 6% cheaper

Dixon 1,662 on sale$16.99 · 6% cheaper

Price by material

Gold

$15-17%

Plastic

$16.99-6%

Wood

$19.99+11%

Silver

$19.99+11%

Steel

$22.94+27%

Sterling Silver

$50.32+180%

Why? Prices range from Gold at 15 to Sterling Silver at 50.32.

Price by brand

Unbranded

$14-22%

Dixon

$16.99-6%

Venus

$18

Faber-Castell

$17.95

Eberhard Faber

$19.99+11%

Black Wing

$31.95+77%

Why? Values vary from Unbranded at 14 to Black Wing at 31.95.

🛒 Some on sale right now

Common questions

What is the median price for a new collectible pencil?

The median price for new listings is 19.99.

Which brand commands the highest premium?

Black Wing pencils have the highest brand median at 31.95.

How does the price of wood pencils compare to the market median?

Wood pencils have a median of 19.99, which is an 11% increase over the market median of 18.

How we got these numbers

Worked out from 200 live eBay listings (price range $7–$75, odd outliers ignored). These are asking prices, so use them as a guide. Last checked June 22, 2026.